Anti-jail fanatics will block Tisch’s crime-fighting plans

New Yorkers are expressing their support for Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch’s plans to tackle crime and disorder in the city. However, it seems that the Democratic establishment in the city is looking to undermine her efforts.

The mayoral candidates and the City Council majority are adamant about downsizing or completely eliminating Rikers Island, the city’s jail complex. They believe in the concept of decarceration, arguing that jails do more harm than good. But the facts and common sense suggest otherwise – jails and prisons play a crucial role in keeping the public safe by preventing criminals from committing further crimes.

A recent City Council hearing on criminal justice painted a picture of a fantasy world. Councilman Lincoln Restler expressed deep concern about the number of incarcerated individuals, while other members urged the Department of Correction to resume the release program initiated during the COVID-19 pandemic, despite evidence showing that many of those released went on to commit more crimes.

It is imperative for organizations like the Police Benevolent Association and the Correction Officers’ Benevolent Association to oppose the city’s plan to close Rikers Island and replace it with four borough-based mini-jails that can only house half of the current prisoner count. This is especially important now that the city has a new police commissioner dedicated to addressing quality-of-life offenses.

While individuals cannot be sent to jail for minor offenses like fare evasion or graffiti, many of these crimes are committed by repeat offenders wanted for more serious offenses. Once apprehended, judges have the option to detain them pre-trial if there is adequate jail capacity. Therefore, the commissioner requires sufficient jail cells to effectively crack down on crime.

Despite the need for jail capacity to ensure public safety, all the leading Democratic mayoral candidates oppose providing the necessary facilities. City Council Speaker Adrienne Adams advocates for alternatives to incarceration, while State Assemblyman Zohran Mamdani emphasizes decarceration and focuses on creating dignified work and well-resourced neighborhoods rather than relying on policing and criminal penalties.

The consequences of the bail reform law signed in 2019 by former Governor Andrew Cuomo have been detrimental, leading to a surge in crime in New York City. The law requires judges to release suspects charged with misdemeanors and even felonies without cash bail, resulting in a spike in criminal activity.

Former Police Commissioner Ray Kelly and retired Assistant District Attorney Jim Quinn warn against the closure of Rikers Island, citing concerns about the planned borough-based jails being more conducive to gang activity. They argue that therapeutic alternatives to incarceration do little to deter crime.

While Rikers Island faces challenges such as deteriorating infrastructure and safety concerns, the solution lies in rebuilding the facility on the island itself. Its location provides secure housing, outdoor recreation areas, and room for expansion if needed.

It is crucial for New Yorkers who prioritize public safety to voice their opposition to the Democratic push for decarceration. Without adequate jail space to prevent criminals from reoffending, Commissioner Tisch’s enforcement efforts will be in vain.